NEWThe Humble Cup: coffee, tea and what a five-dollar cup says about savingNew essay: The Humble CupRead →
The Money Shelf

Claim 4 of 22

Index funds: own the index

Do professional fund managers beat a fund that copies the market?

Verdict

Holds

Over every period of five years or longer, at least 83 per cent of US large-cap funds, at least 92 per cent of UK large- and mid-cap funds and at least 81.6 per cent of Australian equity general funds lagged their index, and the one figure below 80 per cent over those periods, UK small-cap funds over 10 years at 76.62 per cent, is still a majority.

The cost, from the book's own figures. Over ten years the average fund compounded 10,000 to $34,157 against $42,286 for its benchmark in the United States, to £18,877 against £23,051 in the United Kingdom and to A$21,490 against A$24,669 in Australia, which is 19.2, 18.1 and 12.9 per cent less.

Made by: Bogle, Malkiel, Robbins, Booth, Collins, Sethi.

Editions used: SPIVA U.S. Scorecard, Mid-Year 2026 (data to 30 June 2026); SPIVA Europe Scorecard, Year-End 2025 (data to 31 December 2025); SPIVA Australia Scorecard, Mid-Year 2026 (data to 30 June 2026). SPIVA is published by S&P Dow Jones Indices.

Test it on your own numbers

The full test, with every figure dated and sourced, is in chapter 4 of the book.

Go deeper, every month

One email a month with new insights for each section of the book, new country pages, new official figures as they are published, and free money guides. Choose your country so the figures fit you.